You be the judge... So I am walking to
the library of my hospital today, which is right near one of the main
entrances. As I turn the corridor, I hear a voice in Urdu stop me
"Excuse me sir, doctor-sahib." I am met with a slightly restless Pakistani man, probably
in his mid to late 40s. He was in a shirt and tie, an old dark jacket,
an oldish bag, mildly disheveled looking given his imperfectly combed
hair and the anxious look about him, but it did seem like he had gotten
somewhat "dressed up" from his normal attire. He seemed greatful that
he had met another Pakistani, he clearly (and correctly) profiled me from a distance, as he was more comfortable speaking in
Urdu, though he spoke English well. He explained to me he needed some
help and proceeds with his story. He came down to NYC from upstate for
a job interview at a company, whose name he did mention, but I forget
now, and it seemed he is a recent immigrant. He said he was making a phone call at a pay phone, and left his
wallet on top of the payphone as he left. Of course, the wallet was
gone when he returned a few minutes later. I asked him if he filed a
police report, he said he just did that. He came over to
Montefiore to look for a doctor he knew in the area, a "Dr. Nawaz", who
he then discovered had moved his practice from the old location. So
now he finds himself in the doorway of Montefiore, with no money or ID,
and no way to get home. He is very respectful, and I could see the
hint of despair in his eyes, as he comes to me to ask for $38 for bus
fare to return to upstate New York where he lives. He swore to me (and
to Allah) that he would pay it back. I told him to have a seat for a
minute in the lobby, and I said I would be right back, and I took a
walk to size him up real quick in my head...
Now first off, was he legit, or was he trying to swindle me?
He had a pretty convincing story, and by looking at him, he definitely
fit the part of what he portrayed. Now I'll admit, the fact that he
was Pakistani, and speaking to me in Urdu, I felt more of an obligation
to help him. If he was a random white or hispanic guy, I'll admit I
would probably not have even stopped to talk to him for so long, and
gone on my way. That's not even in a racist way, but you always have
somewhat more of a bond and cultural obligation to at least give "your
people" the benefit of the doubt--swindlers or not. Now I lost my
wallet recently, so that definitely made me think about his situation,
which worked in his favor. Moreover, this guy is far away from home,
and nobody to go to for help, so I felt his pain. I mean it was only
$38, and I doubt he developed such an elaborate scheme for just a few
bucks. And the amount was precise, he didn't ask for 20, 50, or
anything, it was $38. I consulted with a coworker who agreed that he
is likely telling the truth. And I mean, what is $38?
So I exchanged address and phone numbers with Mr. Abdul Aziz,
took out $40 from the ATM, and he was on his merry way. He said he
would need 2 to 3 weeks to send me the money, as he was waiting to hear about this new job, and would get money soon. I almost told him to "pay it forward", but he'd likely look at me wondering wtf? Now I give it a 30% I
get the money back, and even if I don't, I don't think I would care.
In the end, I feel good about myself, because I have done my good deed
of the day.
Even if there is that small chance that I have indeed, been duped.
Recent Comments